Missing the Mark: 9 Marks Aren’t Enough 13
Mark Dever pastors the Capital Hill Baptist Church in Washington, DC, one of the most well known Southern Baptist churches in the United States. Dever is well respected by a great number of young, professing fundamentalists, especially for his 9 Marks organization.  What I read at 9 Marks is better than most of what I read in fundamentalism, at least for what fundamentalism writes. I also admit that I believe the 9 Marks. Our church has the 9 Marks. Here is what 9 Marks says is its mission:
We believe the local church is the focal point of God’s plan for displaying his glory to the nations. Our vision is simple: Churches that reflect the character of God. Our mission is to cultivate and encourage churches characterized by these nine marks.
9 Marks then says that these are the nine marks:
- Expositional Preaching
- Biblical Theology
- Biblical Understanding of the Good News
- Biblical Understanding of Conversion
- Biblical Understanding of Evangelism
- Biblical Understanding of Membership
- Biblical Church Discipline
- Promotion of Christian Discipleship and Growth
- Biblical Understanding of Leadership
Have you ever been attempting to describe to someone the type of church he should be looking for? Haven’t you used certain characteristics as the means of that description?  Like 9 Marks, I too want churches to dedicate themselves to certain traits, fleshing out what Scripture says about the church and imitating the distinctives that we see from there, instead of being fad oriented. I desire for men to trust the sufficiency of God’s Word as it relates to their churches, instead of running to conferences to hear what the latest growth or management guru says a church ought to be.
The Baptist Distinctives
I still think that the Baptist Distinctives are nice marks for a church. I wouldn’t recommend a church that did not have them. They are Scriptural and do act as a certain benchmark for obedience to God. They are obviously not everything, but if you look at the Baptist Distinctives, you will see some basics that have historically characterized God’s churches. For those who don’t know them, they are:
- Bible Sole Authority for Faith and Practice
- Regenerate Immersed Church Membership
- Autonomy of Each Church
- Pastor and Deacons:Â Two Church Offices
- Soul Liberty, the Priesthood of the Believer
- Immersion and Lord’s Table:Â Two Church Ordinances
- Separation of Church and State
- Separation Both Personally and Ecclesiastically
Those distinctives should characterize a church and they are a bottom line for what I see as a New Testament Church. I don’t really know if 9 Marks would see the Baptist Distinctives as important as their nine marks. I do.
What’s Missing?